People Break Down The Worst Examples Of A TV Show Dumping A Major Cast Member And Trying To Continue

People Break Down The Worst Examples Of A TV Show Dumping A Major Cast Member And Trying To Continue
Pexels from Pixabay

We're all aware television shows are fake and, heck, even the ones pretending to be real have a certain level of fabrication permeating throughout. That's not why we watch, though, we watch because we want to be invested into believing in a show's characters and their journeys.

So when a character is mysteriously removed from a show with zero explanation it can leave a bad taste in our mouths that never goes away.

Also, in case it isn't clear, SPOILERS ahead for all these shows.

Redditor jsakic99, wanted to hear about:

"What's the most egregious example of a TV show losing a major cast member, but still trying to continue on?"

Not Gone, Just Reborn

"Top Gear"


"Came here to say this. Top Geat BBC is nothing w/o Jezza, Crash and Mr. Slowly."

"I watched a few episodes of the reboot and its a total joke."

"On the other hand i bought amazon prime because of Grand Tour."


No More Troy & Abed In The Morning



"It definitely lost some of its charm without Troy, but Hickey, Elroy, and Frankie were decent. It was still a good show without Troy, just not as good."


Fired For Good Cause

"Criminal Minds comes to mind for me. Thomas Gibson definitely deserved to be fired, but once he was gone the show felt completely different. They should have stopped there instead of trying another season."


"To be fair, they pulled it off once before, when Mandy Patinkin left. Hotch was very much the solid center of the group, after that though, and they never really found someone to fill that role. I love Prentiss, but she doesn't fill that void, and Rossi wouldn't really do either. They would need to find someone that had chemistry with the other characters but still had the darkness that Hotch brought."


How Does Your Family Work?

"Dukes of Hazzard for one season tried to replace Bo and Luke with two other Duke cousins."


"The Coy and Vance situation made the whole Duke family tree even more suspicious. Bo, Luke, Daisy, Coy and Vance all called each other cousin, and called Jesse "uncle". None of them were siblings. Were these all just random children that Jesse "found" and raised? Did Jesse have 5 siblings who each had a child that they were unwilling/unable to care for? Did they all leave their kids with Jesse because a moonshine runner was considered the most respectable? There probably aren't too many social workers in Hazard County, but someone really needs to look into this."



"CSI after Grissom left was never the same"


"I thought Liev Schreiber's short guest-stint standing in for William Petersen was good, but Grissom was kind of integral."


Just Stop Dying

"Grey’s Anatomy used to be good, now everyone’s either dead or left due to various reasons"


A Magical Missing Sister! Of Course!

"So what always hit me as funny was in the TV Show Charmed."

"Basically the entire concept was about three sisters being the chosen triad that together could do amazing magic."

"After a couple seasons all three of them were on the floor "Dying" and it cut off."

"Next season apparently two of the sisters had been saved, but the last one had died off screen and the entire thing was skipped over. "You saved me, X saved Y, but that left Z to die!""

"But how can a show that's entirely about the power of three sisters being the chosen ones continue with one of them gone? Easy, they find a long lost sister and activate her magic!"


Steve? Joe?

"Blues Clues"


"As a child I remember being very confused and not realizing right away it was a different person."



Can't Keep A Look Out For Him

"I hated it when Sharona left in Monk. Natalie just wasn’t the same."


I Want To Believe

"The X-Files after David Duchovny left."


"Something was missing when Mulder was gone. Scully and Mulder dealing with the monster of the week type episodes were the best."


It's A Teaching Hospital...Get It?

"Scrubs final season was so bad that even Dr Cox couldn't save it."


"It was meant to be a spinoff series but wasn't allowed to be branded as such."


For Perhaps Good Reason?

"T.J. Miller as Erlich Bachman in Silicon Valley. He was so much of the soul of that show, it really flagged in the later seasons."

"Definitely worth sticking it out to the end though, the series finale was brilliant"


Your Interest Fades With The Character

"The last season of The Office was terrible."

"Scrubs was never the same."

"Stargate SG1 was just ok after Richard Dean Anderson left. If he was never Col. O'Neill and I started watching the show after he left, I would have watched to the end. Once RDA left so did my interest in the show."


Everything Changes And You Hate It

"Nobody has mentioned the show Valerie? It was named after the main character, Valerie Harper (of Rhoda fame), but she tried to play hardball for more money after a couple of seasons, so they killed her off and changed the name to "Valerie's Family.""

"As if that wasn't enough to swallow, they brought in Sandy Duncan to be the mom-type character, and changed the name AGAIN to "The Hogan Family." I didn't know who Valerie Harper was at the time, but I watched it because the guy who played Ricky Stratton's bad-boy friend on Silver Spoons was on it: Jason Bateman."


We ALL Hate Randy

"That '70s Show"


"We all hate Randy"


"Randy embodies everything people hate about late series main cast replacements. He's a buff pretty boy, unlike Eric, but is still marketed as being a sensitive, nerdy guy, which is what made up a big part of Eric's appeal. He bonds with Red like Eric never could, he immediately takes Eric's place as Donna's love interest and is shunted into the main group without pretense and with little defined character. He's basically Poochie, from the Simpsons, but unironically."


Perhaps The Biggest Of All

"The Office comes to mind, though I enjoy the later seasons too."


"This is the one for me. I'm fine with folks enjoying the last few seasons (and I guarantee there's post-Carrell episodes I enjoy as well) but by and large, it lost a lot of its magic without him. That said, I imagine some key writers departing were also responsible for the tonal shift (where some characters turned into the cartoon versions of themselves while others were seemingly reinvented on the fly)."



"Vikings , after Ragnar died there was nothing left for me tbh , the other actors are all amazing but there aren’t enough developed characters for the show to be interesting anymore "


Yeah, So Sad...

"John Ritter, from 8 Simple Rules for Dating my Teenage Daughter."

"The main character died in the beginning of the second season*. It's a family sit-com, but I remember liking it. And it was starting to build a bit of a following when it happened."


"John Ritter. Died from aortic dissection. So sad."



"Worse, he started having the fatal symptoms when he was on set rehearsing for the next episode. The crew had to rush him to the hospital."


A cast change can work for or against a series.

Did your "worst" make the list?

Want to "know" more?

Sign up for the Knowable newsletter here.

Never miss another big, odd, funny, or heartbreaking moment again.

Until we're in a situation, we'll never really know how we'll react.

I have been in this scenario, though.

Sex matters. And people rarely want to admit how much.

But sex isn't a lifetime guarantee.

It fades, as does love.

It's important to speak about it.

It can be a fixable situation.

A relationship without sex may not be the end of the world, but it's definitely a sign that something is off.

Keep reading...Show less
Two women holding up daisies
Photo by Sam McNamara on Unsplash

An important contributor to our overall health and happiness is the quality of our friendships.

We may not have a lot of friends, but the more important factor is the depth of those relationships.

But we've all had one of those friends who turned out not to be a very good friend at all.

Keep reading...Show less
Couple in love
Jonathan Borba/Unsplash

No one wants to be alone.

But that doesn't mean we should settle when it comes to choosing a romantic partner.

When people rush into things without letting love flourish, it could lead to problems down the line that can inevitably lead to difficult breakups.

Keep reading...Show less

Among the many reasons people watch, and rewatch, sitcoms is to imagine your life was more like the one you were watching.

Being able to afford a two-bedroom apartment in Greenwich Village on a line cook's salary, somehow always having the comfortable sofa available at your favorite coffee shop whenever you pop in, or having your best friends always available at your beck and call whenever you need them.

For the romantics, however, it's wishing you could have a romance like you've seen on television.

True not all sitcom romances are exactly the sort that makes you go all aflutter (Were Ross and Rachel actually on a break? And don't even get me started about Ted and Robin.)

Other sitcom couples are so captivating, though, that we would have given anything to be at their wedding... or at the very least go to their home for dinner every Friday.

And this includes plutonic couples, as there is nothing more heartwarming than a lasting friendship.

Keep reading...Show less