People Explain Which Fictional Villains Actually Had A Good Point​

People Explain Which Fictional Villains Actually Had A Good Point​

Humanity is always way more complex than Hollywood wants it to be. A narrative loves a hero and a villain with no room for sympathy for the villainous.

But people don't usually act like that. Most people act out of what they truly, deeply believe to be right. So chances are, we've all seen a villain on film or TV that we relate to just a little bit.

So when Redditor Winologue asked:

"In which movie did the villain actually have a point?"

Here were some of those answers.

Nobody Puts Baby In A Corner

"Baby's dad in Dirty Dancing. He just wanted to keep a sketchy dance instructor from diddling his daughter."-Willy-Wanger

"Watched this after not seeing it since I was a kid, and realized Baby's dad was also pretty open-minded for the time."-spinderella1780

The Villain Of Tenacious D

"School Of Rock. Principal Mullens definitely had a right to be concerned, No Vacancy had a right to kick him out of the band, and Ned and his girlfriend had a right to be pissed at their roommate for not paying rent."-lomlomlom

"Jack Black characters are often a**holes in his early years if you look at it. He makes a convincing one but without actually being one."-Junckopolo

The Wrath Of Loneliness

"Khan was right, Kirk could have at least sent a fruit basket a long over the years."-MAJORMETAL84

"He probably reported it to Starfleet. 'Oh, btw I found SuperHitler and instead of beelining it to Earth where he can face trial for genocide, I decided to drop him on Planet Australia to see if hard work will mold him into a better person.'"

"'Just figured I'd say something, check up on him or don't, I don't care.'"-captainedwinkrieger

If a movie was made from their point of view, how would the audience feel then?

The Black Pearl

"Barbossa, he just wanted to be uncursed. Granted he was being a real a-hole about it..."-ItssHarrison

"Well, he had been dealing with Jack Sparrow for decades. No one actually likes Jack Sparrow except the audience. His former crew mutinied. He constantly betrays everyone around him."

"He tries to abandon ship by himself when the kraken comes. He makes out with another man's fiancée. And he drinks all the fricking rum. He's only tolerated because he's clever, has a magic compass, and is extremely lucky."-user deleted

Darth Tyranus The Traitor

"Easy. Attack of the Clones. The Villain, Count Dooku, straight up told Obi-wan that the Galactic republic was under control of a Sith Master."

"Which, this bothered me. Ok, so you think Count Dooku was lying. Couldn't like one Jedi double check the vetting on the Chancellor, just to make sure? Wouldn't that have been prudent 'hey, just in case guys, let's look into this.'"-encyclodoc

Hyuckin' Worried

"Now he wasn't really a villain, but he was the antagonist, Goofy in A Goofy Movie had understandably good reasons to be scared for his son from his perspective."-Ussh06

"The real villain was a lack of communication. 'Hey dad before we go on this road trip can I go to this end of the school year party first?'"

"'There's this girl I really like whose going to be there and wanted me to be there too,' was all it would have taken for Goofy to delay the road trip a bit and avoid all the shenanigans."

"Or if that was out of the question, later on he could have said 'Hey dad can we add a stop onto the road trip and go to a concert?' instead of having to get all underhanded and weird..."-Wooper160

I'll Get You My Pretty

"Wizard of Oz. Yeah, she was a witch but c'mon. They were her dead sisters shoes. She should have them. Not some stranger who just showed up and wants them."

"Oh by the way, this stranger that just showed up, was the one that killed her sister. Sad really."-paulvs88

911 Operators Break Down The Strangest Call They've Ever Received | George Takei’s Oh Myyy

"911 what's your emergency?" is the first part of the script. After that, operators rely on their training and instinct. It could be really serious or someth...

Can you imagine an entire perspective into the people society truly wants you to villainize? How would you perceive them?

Ruined By Sam Raimi

"Flint Marko (AKA Sandman) from Spider-Man 3. He's a desperate father with a daughter on her deathbed, just trying to amass the funding necessary to bring her back to health."-CorgisDie

"They really screwed that one up. He coulda been a great sympathetic villain if the studio hadn't forced them into adding Venom. Damned story was pulled in all directions, Marko's character never got any proper development."-jake106

Manifest Destiny

"A really underrated animated film called Battle for Terra. The human race was dying and basically was going to colonize the nearest planet their refugee ships drifted toward, but they would be committing genocide on the native inhabitants due to terraforming."

"The villain was a heartless killer but he made a very good point for doing what he did."

"'Future generations may call me a monster... But because of me, there will be future generations.'"

"I didn't like him, but I couldn't deny that he cared about humanity."-nooshdog


"I don't know if you can really call him the villain but Andrew in Chronicle was right in a twisted way."

"Nobody helps him, everyone does whatever they want with no consideration for how it affects everyone else simply because they can."

"Suddenly when he finds himself with the power to take what he wants and do what he wants, he does just that."-Purplewizzlefrisby

Classist Classic

"Malvolio from Twelfth Night."

"Guy just wanted to be a nobleman and be rich. Is that such a bad dream for a commoner to have?"

"Apparently it is, because to the noblemen, that warrants tricking him, locking him in a cage and gas lighting him. No wonder he wants revenge."

- TheAynRandFan

Purple Rain

"Not a comment on their real-life talents or personalities... heck, Prince wrote The Time's music for the movie... but within the universe of the movie, Morris Day in Purple Rain."

"The Time delivered consistently good shows that the crowd seemed to love, while The Kid was hit and miss because he dragged his personal baggage up onto the stage half the time."

"Not to mention The Kid's dismissive attitude and borderline abusive behavior toward his female bandmates."

"The whole reason Apollonia came to the club in the first place was to put herself on the path to a music career. Morris actually HELPED her with her career and built a band around her; The Kid only valued her as his personal arm candy."

"Was the concept for her band kinda cheesy and exploitative? Sure. But a) it's the 80s and b) the crowd seemed to dig it, so... maybe Morris knew what he was doing."

"Yes, he made a poor-taste joke about the Kid's father's suicide attempt, but keep in mind that the previous evening, The Kid had tried to run him down with his motorcycle. I might be a little mad too."

"And they even show Morris regretting the joke shortly after he said it."

"OK, he also got drunk and made a pass at Apollonia after her first show, but he didn't actually get physical and she was doing an OK job of turning him down... you know, right up until the aforementioned motorcycle attack."

"And then there's the fact that The Kid slapped Apollonia around on... what.. their second, third date? But we're just gonna gloss over that because he wrote a really good song to apologize?"

- pfellah

Give Loki A Throne

"In my opinion, Loki has a point."

"His biological dad Fárbauti had the throne to the giants (as far as I know) His adopted father Odin had a throne, and now his adopted brother Thor gets a throne."

"So I'm kinda a bit on Lokis side about getting a throne its only fair, and also because why not?"

- GodFromOuterSpace1

Muggles Were Dangerous

"Harry Potter. Not Voldemort, but Salazar Slytherin."

"Slytherin existed during a time when witchcraft was being punished with death by the Muggles, so naturally he wouldn't want anyone who could lead the Muggles to the very school they were trying to double as a safe haven."

- barryc100588

Poor Kevin

"The Bee Movie."

"It was a very weird movie overall but Kevin is just some poor dude with allergies that gets dumped for a f*cking bee."

- OuterSpace_KitKat_20

"The boyfriend from The Bee Movie. Everyone else in that movie just happened to be absolutely insane."

- Emmax1997

The Machines Are Right

"Always get sh*t for this when I say it, but the machines from The Matrix."

"Humans originally created them, and when the machines became sentient and tried to coexist in peace, humanity basically said, 'no, go f*ck yourself,' and did everything it could - even going so far as to destroy the planet (!) - to obliterate them."

- rinroz

Did you recognize any of your own traits in the ones described as villainous above? Do you relate to any of the villains in the movies you have seen in your life?

If so, you might be catching onto the idea that humanity is not as simple as we'd like to make it in Hollywood.

Want to "know" more?

Sign up for the Knowable newsletter here.

Never miss another big, odd, funny, or heartbreaking moment again.

Man leaning forward into prison bars
Photo by Pablo Padilla on Unsplash

We're human, and we can acknowledge that we all make mistakes.

But there's a limit to how much grace any person can be shown for their slip-ups.

In fact, there are some mistakes that a person could make in a single day that could ruin the rest of their lives.

Keep reading...Show less
Person wearing a skull mask and shushing the camera
Max Bender/Unsplash

What separates a human being from a monster?

It's an age-old question about humanity. How is a species that is born out of love and blessed with the ability for critical thinking and making others happy capable of committing unspeakable acts of horror?

The scary thing is anyone is capable of the worst kind of crime–taking another's life.

Does it take one unfortunate moment in a fit of rage or cross paths with the wrong individual resulting in a person snapping and killing someone?

Or, are some of us born with the murder gene?

Keep reading...Show less
Woman making a bed
Photo by Volha Flaxeco on Unsplash

People who work in hotels see all kinds of people.

As people from all over the world go in and out of their revolving doors on an almost daily basis.

Though it might be the housekeeping staff who see more than anyone else, and frankly more than they would care to see themselves.

Unlike most of the staff, they have the unique position of going into the guest's rooms.

Of course, they tend to knock to make sure no one's there before entering.

But every now and again, the guests don't hear the knock or put on the "please makeup room" sign on their door instead of "do not disturb."

Leaving the poor cleaning staff with a memories they would likely do anything to forget.

Keep reading...Show less
photo of person's hand on wall
Photo by MontyLov on Unsplash

Sometimes you just get a vibe or a tingle down your neck that you're in the wrong place at the wrong time.

It can be wise to trust this gut instinct, as we learned from many in the Reddit community.

Often those goosebumps or the voice in their head actually saved them from serious harm.

Keep reading...Show less