Americans Confess Whether They'd Vote For An Atheist Presidential Candidate
Element5 Digital on Unsplash

When it comes to electing a leader, the choice is an easy one if a potential candidate shares the same values as yours.


And while a candidate is fit to lead remains to be seen, we rely on our instinct to choose someone with whom we can relate.

But sometimes, our options are limited and we inevitably go with someone who is the lesser of two evils.

Curious to hear from strangers online about a hypothetical, Redditor Cashmeresquid2309 asked:

"Americans of Reddit, would you vote for an openly Atheist presidential candidate? Why or why not?"

Redditors were quick to point out the answer was a no-brainer.

We Already Know The Answer

"Asking Reddit if they'd vote for an atheist..."

"I feel like the answer would be obvious."

– sarahmagoo

Sci-Fi Analogy

"Americans of Reddit, would you vote for a Star Wars fan who heckin loves doggos?"

– WitnessChemical

For The Atheists In The Crowd

"Atheists of atheistville, would you vote for an open atheist?"

– nixcamic

Others weighed in with a range of opinions.

Redirect, Please

"Better to ask the question in r/conservative"

– DoctorTacoMD

About 45

"What's funny is how many of them would probably say no, even though they voted for Trump and would do so again. Say whatever else you want about him, but I seriously can't understand how anyone could genuinely believe Trump is a Christian. He's so obviously faking it and is undoubtedly the most atheistic president we've ever had or are likely to have for a long time."

"This is a guy who's never even so much as read the Bible or attended church, who told a conservative radio host his favorite Bible verse was 'an eye for an eye', who told evangelical interviewers that he's never asked God for forgiveness because he's never done anything wrong, and who routinely commits all 7 deadly sins (pride, greed, wrath, envy, lust, gluttony and sloth) without remorse."

– empfindsamkeit

From A Different Perspective

"Not an american but interestingly according to this survey on 1006 people from 2007, being atheist was the worst thing you could be as a candidate (of the things asked) with only 45 % of people saying they'd vote for one."

– ilovecatfish

An atheist candidate isn't necessarily a big strike.

Double Negative

"I wouldn’t not vote for someone just because they were atheist."

– HabitualEnthusiast

Credibility First

"This is it. If they’re running on platforms I support with a history to back up those campaign promises, I don’t care if they belong to the church of the flying spaghetti monster. They could literally be a member of the satanic temple and I, an actual practicing Christian, would give less shi*s than a constipated sloth."

"Edit: yes, I realize the Satanic Temple does not actually worship satan. I used it for that purpose. The Church of Satan has some…problematic views and I probably would not vote for someone who literally holds a platform of eugenics."

– Phoenix_of_Asclepius

Some view the role of religion in politics as important.

It Depends

"Religion can be relevant: I would have strong reservations about voting for a Scientologist, even if I agreed with the policies they proposed. I would have strong reservations voting for a member of an apocalyptic cult or, possibly worse, a follower of the (highly heretical) 'prosperity gospel,' which unfortunately includes more and more so-called 'evangelicals' — I didn't vote for George W. Bush, but it's not because he was an evangelical."

"It depends on the role: I'd probably be more flexible with a legislator than an executive (mayor, governor, president), as their character is IMO more important than for a legislator and their policy stances somewhat less important relative to a legislator."

"Satanic temple — well, that's just an organized group of atheists and humanists with an intentionally inflammatory choice of name. They're generally fine people."

– alyssasaccount

A Bad Rap

"The Satanic Temple is an excellent organization that every decent person should be able to respect. A Church of Satan member, not so much."

"There's a huge difference between them!"

– StarsEatArtBooks

And Redditor boganvegan said it best.

"Better an open atheist than a fake Christian."

It all boils down to trustworthiness. Without full transparency, how could anyone put their faith in a candidate who spews nothing but lies?

Want to "know" more?

Sign up for the Knowable newsletter here.

Never miss another big, odd, funny or heartbreaking moment again.

People Share The Most Terrifying Historical Facts They Know
Gerasimov174/GettyImages

History is full of infamous disasters one can't imagine experiencing in their lifetimes.

Keep reading...Show less
People Debate Which Famous Historical Figures Would Be Surprised To Learn About Their Fame
Mika Baumeister/Unsplash

Fame is one of those things people tend to want until they have it - or that people shy away from entirely because they understand how sideways it tends to go.

But what about people who end up famous after their deaths? Or who managed to get more famous from the afterlife?

Keep reading...Show less
People Imagine What They'd Like To See On An NSFW MythBusters Episode
Photo by Erik Lucatero on Unsplash

Don't you love a good myth?

Us too.

Let's put some of NSFW ones to the test.

RedditorWizzlyG33wanted to hear about what lies need to be exposed when it comes to sex, death and all things over the top in life. They asked:

"If MythBusters had a NSFW episode, what would you want to see on it?"
Keep reading...Show less
People Divulge How They Cope With Loneliness
Photo by Anthony Tran on Unsplash

Many people value solitude, and having time to themselves.

For others though, loneliness can be a crippling feeling.

Having no one to talk to or spend time with can get wearying after an extended amount of time.

Something many people know more than ever after the global pandemic hit in spring of 2020.

But while some people simply succumb to being lonely, others will find ways to help them cope with, if not completely forget, being all alone.

Redditor No_Blackberry_6286 was curious to hear the different ways people have of coping with their loneliness, leading them to ask:

"Reddit, how do you cope with loneliness?"
Keep reading...Show less